New Video - With AUDIO message of Jathedaar of Sri Akaal Takht Sahib.
New Video - With AUDIO message of Jathedaar of Sri Akaal Takht Sahib.
In here you can here Singh Sahib, clearly saying that Progs should be cancelled and true vidvaans (scholars) called!
He questions why Sarbjit came to UK, to break or join the Sangat with Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaaj...
To the editor of the video above: Those small clips of youtube videos show Prof Dhunda encouraging all Sikhs to follow only the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Perhaps you could cut and paste those parts of the Sikh Rehat Maryada that you believe Prof Dhunda has violated, in order to back up your article.
Deh Shiva is not Bani??? (Which marayda is this in?!) 5 pyare have no right to disencourage eating meat? (what marayda is this? AKJ (all branches) DDT, Nanaksar etc are all wrong? even Nihang Singhs say only Chatka is ok NOTHING else, this guy is saying its all good "jih fit aunda chak leh" lol!!!)
The list goes on...
Please actually answer the questions posed in the previous articles...
Apologies, I think you mis-understood my question. The video clip started with the Jathedaar of the Akal Takht (being the authority) making the decision on whether or not Prof Dhunda should speak. So that shows you follow what the Akal Takht orders which I entirely agree with.
The Akal Takht (via the Jathedaar) enforces the Sikh Rehat Maryada (Sikh Code of Conduct) on all Sikhs which we MUST adhere to.
I didn't ask for your summary on the videos. My question was, which parts of this Code of Conduct has Prof Dhunda actually violated? I'm not arguing with you. I'm just after some clarification, that's all.
Are you saying the Akhand Keertni Jatha, Damdami Taksal, Nanaksar or any other similar sect/jathebandi can be above the Akal Takht and its Code of Conduct? That seems wrong to me. My understanding was that ALL Sikhs, regardless of which sect/jathebandi they belong to, MUST comply with the Akal Takht's Code of Conduct. Are you saying this is wrong?
Anyone that violates this Code of Conduct is wrong, whether this is Prof Dhunda or anyone else. But from your selected video clips, I couldn't see that he had violated the Code of Conduct.
I look forward to receiving your clarification. Thank you.
Akaal Takht sandesh 2006 / + as part of his tankhaah he was told not to talk about Sri Dasam Granth - the Bani of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj.
He has violated that for one.
According to my understanding of your previous message, one can say and do what they want so long as they don't talk about marayda?? They can cuss Gurmat principles, but thats ok???
I may be wrong but I think those video's are pre the Sandesh. My understanding is that I don't believe he has spoken of the Dasam Granth since the Sandesh, but I'm happy to be corrected if I've got that wrong.
I agree that no-one (Prof Dhunda, a fake sant baba or anyone else)has the right to talk ill of our Gurbani whatsoever, but sadly "Gurmat" has been so diluted with "manmat" today and as much as we think we're following Gurmat, many of us are inadvertently following manmat without even realising it.
I don't like to follow a crowd blindly or jump to rash conclusions after seeing only small clips where things can be taken greatly out of context, which is why I sought your clarification. I really didn't get an answer but thanks for your reply, appreciated. I'll continue to watch his full video recordings on youtube to come to a conclusion.
The full videos are available under Dhundas organisations youtube channel "Sikhilehar" The Nagpur video is June 2012, where he cusses Deh Shiva (Sikh National Anthem).
Akaal Takht Sandesh on Dasam Bani: 2006 Dhundas Tankhaah: Feb 2012.
Watch full clips and learn for yourself, a quick sidenote most of the small videos are made by Sikhi Lehar (cut from his bigger videos!!!).
So if they have made them small clips, its show what Dhunda (and the organisation) believe in.
If you wish to carry on supporting such people who openly cuss our Guru's Bani... Then good luck, its up2you.
To the editor of the video above: Those small clips of youtube videos show Prof Dhunda encouraging all Sikhs to follow only the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Perhaps you could cut and paste those parts of the Sikh Rehat Maryada that you believe Prof Dhunda has violated, in order to back up your article.
ReplyDeleteMuch appreciated and many thanks.
Harjit Kaur,
ReplyDeleteSikh Rehat Marayda?
Deh Shiva is not Bani??? (Which marayda is this in?!)
5 pyare have no right to disencourage eating meat? (what marayda is this? AKJ (all branches) DDT, Nanaksar etc are all wrong? even Nihang Singhs say only Chatka is ok NOTHING else, this guy is saying its all good "jih fit aunda chak leh" lol!!!)
The list goes on...
Please actually answer the questions posed in the previous articles...
Thanks
Dear Sarbjit
ReplyDeleteApologies, I think you mis-understood my question. The video clip started with the Jathedaar of the Akal Takht (being the authority) making the decision on whether or not Prof Dhunda should speak. So that shows you follow what the Akal Takht orders which I entirely agree with.
The Akal Takht (via the Jathedaar) enforces the Sikh Rehat Maryada (Sikh Code of Conduct) on all Sikhs which we MUST adhere to.
I didn't ask for your summary on the videos. My question was, which parts of this Code of Conduct has Prof Dhunda actually violated? I'm not arguing with you. I'm just after some clarification, that's all.
Are you saying the Akhand Keertni Jatha, Damdami Taksal, Nanaksar or any other similar sect/jathebandi can be above the Akal Takht and its Code of Conduct? That seems wrong to me. My understanding was that ALL Sikhs, regardless of which sect/jathebandi they belong to, MUST comply with the Akal Takht's Code of Conduct. Are you saying this is wrong?
Anyone that violates this Code of Conduct is wrong, whether this is Prof Dhunda or anyone else. But from your selected video clips, I couldn't see that he had violated the Code of Conduct.
I look forward to receiving your clarification. Thank you.
Akaal Takht sandesh 2006 / + as part of his tankhaah he was told not to talk about Sri Dasam Granth - the Bani of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj.
ReplyDeleteHe has violated that for one.
According to my understanding of your previous message, one can say and do what they want so long as they don't talk about marayda??
They can cuss Gurmat principles, but thats ok???
Thanks for your reply.
ReplyDeleteI may be wrong but I think those video's are pre the Sandesh. My understanding is that I don't believe he has spoken of the Dasam Granth since the Sandesh, but I'm happy to be corrected if I've got that wrong.
I agree that no-one (Prof Dhunda, a fake sant baba or anyone else)has the right to talk ill of our Gurbani whatsoever, but sadly "Gurmat" has been so diluted with "manmat" today and as much as we think we're following Gurmat, many of us are inadvertently following manmat without even realising it.
I don't like to follow a crowd blindly or jump to rash conclusions after seeing only small clips where things can be taken greatly out of context, which is why I sought your clarification. I really didn't get an answer but thanks for your reply, appreciated. I'll continue to watch his full video recordings on youtube to come to a conclusion.
Kind regards
The full videos are available under Dhundas organisations youtube channel "Sikhilehar"
ReplyDeleteThe Nagpur video is June 2012, where he cusses Deh Shiva (Sikh National Anthem).
Akaal Takht Sandesh on Dasam Bani: 2006
Dhundas Tankhaah: Feb 2012.
Watch full clips and learn for yourself, a quick sidenote most of the small videos are made by Sikhi Lehar (cut from his bigger videos!!!).
So if they have made them small clips, its show what Dhunda (and the organisation) believe in.
If you wish to carry on supporting such people who openly cuss our Guru's Bani...
Then good luck, its up2you.
Thanks
I'll look them up, thank you.
ReplyDelete